Sold Homes in Horseshoe Lake, Loveland

Your Horseshoe Lake, Loveland Homes Specialists

Area Information

Sold Home Stats
- Sold Home Stats for
  Horseshoe Lake
  2025 - 2026
  # of Sold Homes: 14
  Avg. Sold Price: $1,692,770
  
  Horseshoe Lake Loveland Sold Homes
  
  Horseshoe Lake Loveland Housing Market Report

Home Search

Property Type:
Single Family
Condo / Townhome

City:

Neighborhood:

Zip:

Price:
TO:

Bedrooms:

Bathrooms:

For a more detailed home search, click For a more detailed home search, click here

HOA Contact
- Management Contact:
  Peninsula at Horseshoe Lake
- Management Phone:
- Search all Denver Metro HOAs
Household Income
- Under $25,000:
  18.3%
- $25,000-$34,999:
  9.6%
- $35,000-$49,999:
  11.4%
- $50,000-$74,999:
  21.8%
- $75,000-$99,9999:
  14.6%
- $100,000-$149,999:
  16%
- $150,000-$199,999:
  5%
- $200,000+:
  3.3%
- Based on zip code.
  Source: U.S. Census Bureau
Education Level
- High School:
  94.1%
- College:
  36.2%
- Graduate and Above:
  12.3%
- Based on zip code.
  Source: U.S. Census Bureau
Crime Rates
- Agency Reporting:
  Loveland Police Dept
- Total Population:
  69,147
- Violent Crime Total:
  145
- Murder / Manslaughter:
  0
- Forecible Rape:
  22
- Robery:
  22
- Aggrivated Assault:
  101
- Property Crime Total:
  1,798
- Burglary:
  227
- Larceny / Theft:
  1,525
- Vehicle Theft:
  46
- Sources: FBI, Uniform Crime Reports, prepared by the National Archive of Criminal Justice Data

The Brian Petrelli Team is your Horseshoe Lake , Loveland home specialist.

Horseshoe Lake Community Information:

Primary HOA Fees*:
$285.00 / Quarterly

Secondary HOA Fees*:
$300.00 / Annually

*HOA fees shown are from the most recent listings. Please contact our team or check each property individually for accurate HOA fees. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed.

HOA Ammenities:
-Park
-Reserves

Horseshoe Lake , Loveland has had 14 homes sell in the past two years for an average sales price of $1,692,770.

Our team of local Loveland experts have over 200 years of combined expertise in the Colorado Real Estate market. Give us a call today to put our knowledge and experience to work for you as you buy or sell your next Horseshoe Lake home.

Don't see what you're looking for here? Contact our team for a free, custom search.

The Brian Petrelli Team
Phone:303-726-1874
properties@petrelliteam.com

Click here to create your own custom home search. You will be able to search every Loveland houses currently on the market.

Loveland Home Searches

Loveland Horse Properties

Loveland Single Family Homes

Loveland Buyer's Agent Information


All Sold Horseshoe Lake Loveland Homes: (Showing most recent sold homes. For complete results, Search All Sold Homes Here) See All Active Horseshoe Lake Loveland Homes For Sale


Your search resulted in 14 Total Homes. Now viewing listings 1 through 14.
Viewing Page 1 of 1. \| Go to Page Go \|

3799 flagler avenue loveland, CO 80538 Horseshoe Lake	2 Beds 2 Baths 2800 Fin SqFt Close Price: $679,000 Close Date: 2026-08-20 List Price: $679,000 # of Photos Avail: 48 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1062773 Status: closed Listing Office: 8z real estate	Broker Remarks: Located on the peninsula of Horseshoe Lake, this home sits within a coveted private community - water on three sides, mountain views to the west, and 91 acres of protected conservation land that ensures the surroundings stay untouched.Inside, the home has been completely reimagined - this open layout is finished with materials and craftsmanship typically reserved for custom builds. Refinished solid oak hardwood floors anchor the main living spaces beneath vaulted ceilings with wood beams, where a fireplace with hand-painted tile surround and abundant natural light. This premium corner lot back.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


1634 animas place loveland, CO 80538 Horseshoe Lake	2 Beds 2 Baths 2169 Fin SqFt Close Price: $575,000 Close Date: 2026-08-04 List Price: $550,000 # of Photos Avail: 37 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1063132 Status: closed Listing Office: group centerra	Broker Remarks: Low maintenance living awaits in this meticulously cared for patio home, perfectly situated in the desirable Horseshoe Lake subdivision, where lakes, trails, dining, and shopping are all nearby for your convenience and outdoor adventures! Step inside to an open concept design flooded with natural light, large windows, hardwood floors, and vaulted ceilings. The heart of the home is the pristine kitchen that flows seamlessly into a cozy living room with a warm fireplace. The updated kitchen boasts an abundance of cabinet and counter space, newer appliances, soft-close cabinetry, and a gas stovet.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


3731 osier place loveland, CO 80538 Horseshoe Lake	3 Beds 3 Baths 2495 Fin SqFt Close Price: $630,000 Close Date: 2026-07-23 List Price: $630,000 # of Photos Avail: 36 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1062238 Status: closed Listing Office: group centerra	Broker Remarks: Welcome to 3731 Osier Place, a beautifully maintained ranch style home nestled in the highly desirable Peninsula at Horseshoe Lake, offering Front Range and lake views in a peaceful, picturesque setting. Built in 2005 by Don Burns Construction Co., this quality crafted residence features nearly 2,500 finished square feet, 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, convenient main level living, and a partially finished basement. The inviting main floor includes a spacious living room with a cozy corner gas fireplace, a formal dining area, and an eat-in kitchen designed for everyday comfort and entertaining. The .. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


2152 seven lakes drive loveland, CO 80538 Horseshoe Lake	5 Beds 5 Baths 4209 Fin SqFt Close Price: $950,000 Close Date: 2026-03-26 List Price: $950,000 # of Photos Avail: 46 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1045603 Status: closed Listing Office: group harmony	Broker Remarks: Enjoy Lakeside Living with Spectacular Mountain views. Stunning two-story home with elegant finishes. Marvelous kitchen, large island, numerous cabinets along with a walk-in pantry. Open floor plan where sleek built-ins surround the gas fireplace, and a dramatic wall of windows that frame the beauty of Horseshoe Lake. Main Floor Primary with 5-piece bath, newer California closet, with a scenic view of the lake. Walkout basement features a spacious family room with a cozy fireplace and wet bar, a flexible room serving as a game room, office, or guest suite, a separate card-playing area, plus ad.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


2272 seven lakes drive loveland, CO 80538 Horseshoe Lake	4 Beds 5 Baths 3526 Fin SqFt Close Price: $975,000 Close Date: 2026-01-30 List Price: $975,000 # of Photos Avail: 50 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1049122 Status: closed Listing Office: group harmony	Broker Remarks: Stunning mountain, lake, and open space views define this luxurious Colorado Craftsman patio home in the highly sought-after Horseshoe Lake community. Backing to protected open space and overlooking the lake, this residence offers exceptional privacy, scenery, and refined living. With exterior lawn, landscaping and snow removal taken care of, this ranch floorplan is ideal for those looking for a simpler way of life yet still with incredible views and the feeling of space.The main level features a grand entry, open floor plan, hardwood floors, elegant fireplace, formal dining area, and two main.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


3782 miramonte avenue loveland, CO 80538 Horseshoe Lake	3 Beds 4 Baths 2821 Fin SqFt Close Price: $545,000 Close Date: 2026-01-29 List Price: $575,000 # of Photos Avail: 50 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1047516 Status: closed Listing Office: group harmony	Broker Remarks: Welcome to this inviting two-story patio home designed for comfort and low-maintenance living. The thoughtful floor plan features a spacious main-level primary suite with a private bath, offering convenience and privacy. The open-concept living and dining areas are filled with natural light and flow seamlessly into the well-appointed kitchen, making it perfect for gatherings or quiet evenings at home. Upstairs, additional bedrooms and a full bath provide versatile space for family, guests, or a home office. The finished basement expands your living options with a large rec room, flex areas, an.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


4263 roaring fork drive loveland, CO 80538 Horseshoe Lake	5 Beds 7 Baths 7213 Fin SqFt Close Price: $3,750,000 Close Date: 2025-10-17 List Price: $3,849,783 # of Photos Avail: 40 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1038610 Status: closed Listing Office: kentwood re northern prop llc	Broker Remarks: Live the lifestyle you've always imagined in this stunning custom lakefront two-story home with a finished walkout basement, nestled on 2.2 acres with panoramic views of the Rocky Mountains, listed below appraised value! Situated on private Horseshoe Lake, this property offers the ultimate in luxury waterfront living. Enjoy an active and serene lifestyle with direct access to all your favorite water sports-start your mornings paddleboarding in calm waters, spend the day waterskiing or surfing, and cap it off with a peaceful pontoon cruise while fishing. Relax with ease: soak up the sun on your.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


2276 seven lakes drive loveland, CO 80538 Horseshoe Lake	5 Beds 5 Baths 3745 Fin SqFt Close Price: $980,000 Close Date: 2025-09-04 List Price: $995,000 # of Photos Avail: 40 V-tour Available: No MLS #: IR1039033 Status: closed Listing Office: group mulberry	Broker Remarks: Welcome to 2276 Seven Lakes Dr. Homes in the Enclave at Horseshoe Lake do not come available often. This is your opportunity to get into this neighborhood now. Built with incredible attention to detail, this is a meticulously cared for south-facing patio home which offers stunning views of Horseshoe Lake to the east AND mountain views over private open space to the west. The spacious ranch-style "lock and leave" property features 5 bedrooms and 5 bathrooms, with an open floor plan ideal for entertaining. Enjoy a chef's kitchen complete with granite counters, stainless steel appliances, gas ran.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


3941 roaring fork drive loveland, CO 80538 Horseshoe Lake	6 Beds 5 Baths 6364 Fin SqFt Close Price: $2,950,000 Close Date: 2025-08-06 List Price: $3,250,000 # of Photos Avail: 40 V-tour Available: No MLS #: IR1039232 Status: closed Listing Office: group centerra	Broker Remarks: This exceptional 2.09-acre lakefront estate in the coveted Peninsula at Horseshoe Lake offers unparalleled privacy and stunning views of Longs Peak and the snow-capped Front Range. Enjoy direct access to one of Colorado's premier 650-acre motorized lakes-ideal for water skiing, boating, and paddleboarding from your backyard. The property features a private dock, sandy beach, volleyball pit, lakefront pergola, and meticulously landscaped grounds with irrigation from both potable water and the lake. With over 6,700 square feet of luxurious living space, this custom-built residence includes six b.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


3861 poudre drive loveland, CO 80538 Horseshoe Lake	3 Beds 3 Baths 2079 Fin SqFt Close Price: $750,000 Close Date: 2025-07-25 List Price: $750,000 # of Photos Avail: 36 V-tour Available: No MLS #: IR1036795 Status: closed Listing Office: re/max nexus	Broker Remarks: Stunning CUSTOM 3 bedroom ranch home in highly sought after Horseshoe Lake backing to neighborhood park. Beautiful open floor plan with large format tile throughout for ease of maintenance. Fireplace in the living room, Cherry Cabinets with soft close doors and drawers, custom built-in pantry, granite counters, top of the line appliances, custom exhaust hood and 5 burner gas stove make the perfect space for your inner chef. Primary suite has a fireplace for those cold nights, 5 piece ensuite with a deep soaking tub, dual vanities and oversized luxury shower, large walk-in closet with custom bu.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


1650 animas place loveland, CO 80538 Horseshoe Lake	3 Beds 3 Baths 3026 Fin SqFt Close Price: $585,000 Close Date: 2025-06-23 List Price: $585,000 # of Photos Avail: 38 V-tour Available: No MLS #: IR1011643 Status: closed Listing Office: liberty associates, llc	Broker Remarks: EXCLUSIVE PENINSULA OF HORSESHOE LAKE! PRICE REDUCED 5/22/25 AND IS BEING SOLD AS IS AT THIS NEW PRICE. Please inspect as it's in good overall condition. Properties here are limited, so why not live where others can only vacation!? Pristine and private peninsula, mountain and water views, 90 acres of Conservation land, walkable to Boyd Lake State Park with marina, camping, fishing, swimming and water sports. Miles of bike paths connect Loveland and Fort Collins to diverse natural areas, trails and parks. About 15 mins to Horsetooth Mountain and 30 mins to Estes Park and Rocky Mountain National.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


1650 animas place loveland, CO 80538 Horseshoe Lake	3 Beds 3 Baths 3026 Fin SqFt Close Price: $585,000 Close Date: 2025-06-23 List Price: $585,000 # of Photos Avail: 38 V-tour Available: No MLS #: 4877531 Status: closed Listing Office: mb liberty associates llc	Broker Remarks: EXCLUSIVE PENINSULA OF HORSESHOE LAKE PATIO HOME! SELLER JUST DROPPED THE PRICE ($585,000 ON 5/22/2025) to their bottom line price. At this price the seller is selling as is and won't be doing any inspection repairs-Please inspect as it's in good overall shape. Properties here are limited so why not live where others can only vacation!? Pristine and private peninsula, mountain and water views, 90 acres of Conservation land, walkable to Boyd Lake State Park with marina, camping, fishing, swimming and water sports. Miles of bike paths connect Loveland and Fort Collins to diverse natural areas,.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


3975 roaring fork drive loveland, CO 80538 Horseshoe Lake	6 Beds 7 Baths 6407 Fin SqFt Close Price: $4,080,000 Close Date: 2025-06-12 List Price: $4,200,000 # of Photos Avail: 40 V-tour Available: No MLS #: IR1032022 Status: closed Listing Office: andersen real estate	Broker Remarks: Welcome to your luxury oasis, nestled on 1.9 acres of pristine landscaping, offering unparalleled features for the discerning homeowner with a breathtaking view of Horseshoe Lake. Arrive in style with ample garage space for your vehicles and watercraft. Experience the ultimate waterfront living with your own private dock access, complete with a grill, refrigerator, and fire pit. Every day is an opportunity for waterfront living at its finest, allowing you to explore the tranquil waters at your leisure. Step inside to discover a world of sophistication and comfort. A grand glass staircase becko.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


4557 roaring fork court loveland, CO 80538 Horseshoe Lake	5 Beds 8 Baths 9639 Fin SqFt Close Price: $5,125,000 Close Date: 2025-02-26 List Price: $5,125,000 # of Photos Avail: 3 V-tour Available: No MLS #: IR1027196 Status: closed Listing Office: re/max alliance-loveland	Broker Remarks: SOLD OFF MARKET, PLEASE CONTACT LANI CARWIN 970-371-4144 WITH ANY QUESTIONS.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


Searches For Homes Near Horseshoe Lake Loveland: See All Loveland Homes For Sale See All Conrad Ball Junior High / Middle School Homes For Sale See All Mountain View Senior High School Homes For Sale The content relating to real estate for sale in this web site comes in part from the Internet Data eXchange ("IDX") program of METROLIST, INC., DBA RECOLORADO® Real estate listings held by brokers other than The Brian Petrelli Team are marked with the IDX Logo. This information is being provided for the consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose. All information subject to change and should be independently verified.