Sold Homes in Old Town, Fort Collins

Your Old Town, Fort Collins Homes Specialists

Area Information

Sold Home Stats
- Sold Home Stats for
  Old Town
  2024 - 2025
  # of Sold Homes: 71
  Avg. Sold Price: $836,697
  
  Old Town Fort Collins Sold Homes
  
  Old Town Fort Collins Housing Market Report

Home Search

Property Type:
Single Family
Condo / Townhome

City:

Neighborhood:

Zip:

Price:
TO:

Bedrooms:

Bathrooms:

For a more detailed home search, click For a more detailed home search, click here

HOA Contact
- Management Contact:
- Management Phone:
- Search all Denver Metro HOAs
Household Income
- Under $25,000:
  35.2%
- $25,000-$34,999:
  10.2%
- $35,000-$49,999:
  15.1%
- $50,000-$74,999:
  16%
- $75,000-$99,9999:
  10.2%
- $100,000-$149,999:
  9.3%
- $150,000-$199,999:
  1.6%
- $200,000+:
  2.4%
- Based on zip code.
  Source: U.S. Census Bureau
Education Level
- High School:
  95.7%
- College:
  51.2%
- Graduate and Above:
  20.2%
- Based on zip code.
  Source: U.S. Census Bureau
Crime Rates
- Agency Reporting:
  Fort Collins Police Dept
- Total Population:
  148,792
- Violent Crime Total:
  391
- Murder / Manslaughter:
  2
- Forecible Rape:
  44
- Robery:
  40
- Aggrivated Assault:
  305
- Property Crime Total:
  4,119
- Burglary:
  598
- Larceny / Theft:
  3,379
- Vehicle Theft:
  142
- Sources: FBI, Uniform Crime Reports, prepared by the National Archive of Criminal Justice Data

The Brian Petrelli Team is your Old Town , Fort Collins home specialist.

Old Town , Fort Collins has had 71 homes sell in the past two years for an average sales price of $836,697.

Our team of local Fort Collins experts have over 200 years of combined expertise in the Colorado Real Estate market. Give us a call today to put our knowledge and experience to work for you as you buy or sell your next Old Town home.

Don't see what you're looking for here? Contact our team for a free, custom search.

The Brian Petrelli Team
Phone:303-726-1874
properties@petrelliteam.com

Click here to create your own custom home search. You will be able to search every Fort Collins houses currently on the market.

Fort Collins Home Searches

Fort Collins 55 And Over Communities

Fort Collins Single Family Homes

Fort Collins Buyer's Agent Information


All Sold Old Town Fort Collins Homes: (Showing most recent sold homes. For complete results, Search All Sold Homes Here) See All Active Old Town Fort Collins Homes For Sale


Your search resulted in 68 Total Homes. Now viewing listings 1 through 15.
Viewing Page 1 of 5. \| Go to Page Go \| Next >>

416 e elizabeth street fort collins, CO 80524 Old Town	4 Beds 2 Baths 1850 Fin SqFt Close Price: Close Date: 2025-07-04 List Price: $650,000 # of Photos Avail: 38 V-tour Available: No MLS #: IR1035522 Status: closed Listing Office: downtown real estate brokers	Broker Remarks: Meticulously maintained Duplex Bungalow on the East Side. Typically, two unit dwellings tend to have deferred maintenance but not 416 E Elizabeth. These owners have made significant investments in the systems of this property making it a turn-key investment for the next owner. Features include: a new roof in 2019, new interior plumbing, new interior wiring, a top of the line boiler and side arm in 2012, a new sewer line, all new interior and exterior paint, new carpet in the basement, new egress windows (during the time of ownership). This property was most recently rented for $1650 / month up.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


601 garfield street fort collins, CO 80524 Old Town	5 Beds 2 Baths 1956 Fin SqFt Close Price: Close Date: 2025-07-01 List Price: $799,000 # of Photos Avail: 36 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1030901 Status: closed Listing Office: coldwell banker realty- fort collins	Broker Remarks: Nestled on a desirable corner lot in Old Town east, this 5-bedroom, 2-bathroom home built in 1900 is brimming with character and vintage charm. Featuring restored original hardwood floors, high ceilings, a claw foot bathtub and a main floor primary. This home maintains its classic "old house" allure and has abundant storage (rare!), lots of natural light and some essential high-ticket upgrades in place. A new roof, new mechanicals, newer kitchen appliances, new interior and exterior paint, a major restoration of exterior siding, added insulation, new light fixtures, a custom California Closet .. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


238 n sherwood street fort collins, CO 80521 Old Town	2 Beds 1 Baths 1361 Fin SqFt Close Price: Close Date: 2025-06-27 List Price: $725,000 # of Photos Avail: 40 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: 3148667 Status: closed Listing Office: c3 real estate solutions llc	Broker Remarks: Adorable in every way, Quintessential Old Town Craftsman Bungalow perfectly reimagined with organic modern feel + a kiss of vintage! So many improvements, ready to move-in and enjoy! PRIME Old Town Fort Collins location on desirable Sherwood just 4 blocks from College + Old Town Square + minutes from 4 parks and the Poudre River Trail + 3 blocks Lee Martinez Park, shopping, restaurants + festivals = so close to everything! Easy open concept layout with 1,361 finished square feet! Oversized, fully fenced-in yard with front, back sprinkler and drip lines, double gate on driveway, west facing wit.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


238 n sherwood street fort collins, CO 80521 Old Town	2 Beds 1 Baths 1361 Fin SqFt Close Price: Close Date: 2025-06-27 List Price: $725,000 # of Photos Avail: 40 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1033326 Status: closed Listing Office: c3 real estate solutions, llc	Broker Remarks: Adorable in every way, Quintessential Old Town Craftsman Bungalow perfectly reimagined with organic modern feel + a kiss of vintage! So many improvements, ready to move-in and enjoy! PRIME Old Town Fort Collins location on desirable Sherwood just 4 blocks from College + Old Town Square + minutes from 4 parks and the Poudre River Trail + 3 blocks Lee Martinez Park, shopping, restaurants + festivals = so close to everything! Easy open concept layout with 1,361 finished square feet! Oversized, fully fenced-in yard with front, back sprinkler and drip lines, double gate on driveway, west facing wit.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


415 sycamore street fort collins, CO 80521 Old Town	3 Beds 2 Baths 978 Fin SqFt Close Price: Close Date: 2025-06-25 List Price: $485,000 # of Photos Avail: 15 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1035250 Status: closed Listing Office: group mulberry	Broker Remarks: Welcome to your own slice of Old Town charm! This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom, 1925 home sits on a private, beautifully landscaped lot on a cul-de-sac in the heart of Old Town Fort Collins. Inside, you'll find new hardwood floors that add warmth and character while honoring the home's original charm. With Lee Martinez Park at your front door, you'll have access to tennis and basketball courts, softball fields, playgrounds, an interactive petting zoo, and the Poudre River. Whether you're looking for a family picnic, active time at the park or some weekend relaxation, it is all right at your front doo.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


256 cajetan street fort collins, CO 80524 Old Town	4 Beds 4 Baths 2503 Fin SqFt Close Price: Close Date: 2025-06-24 List Price: $875,000 # of Photos Avail: 39 V-tour Available: No MLS #: IR1031237 Status: closed Listing Office: group mulberry	Broker Remarks: This stunning urban contemporary home near Old Town is full of wow-factor! With 4 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms, it blends sleek design with comfort and functionality. Enjoy a spiral staircase leading to a private rooftop patio-perfect for taking in Colorado's sunsets and mountain views. The spacious primary suite feels like a true retreat, featuring a spa-inspired 5-piece bath. Designer touches throughout include engineered hardwood floors, a dramatic three-sided fireplace, custom barn doors, white quartz countertops, and stylish lighting. The professionally finished basement offers a wet bar and .. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


505 smith street fort collins, CO 80524 Old Town	2 Beds 1 Baths 754 Fin SqFt Close Price: Close Date: 2025-06-18 List Price: $500,000 # of Photos Avail: 40 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1033892 Status: closed Listing Office: kittle real estate	Broker Remarks: Charming, character-rich, and packed with updates-this Old Town gem is the total package! This beautifully maintained ranch home in the heart of historic Fort Collins sits just minutes from the city's thriving downtown scene, rich with culture, craft breweries, and a diverse dining and shopping scene. Inside, you'll find a warm and welcoming vibe with hardwood floors in most spaces, original architecture that nods to the home's history, and updates that make daily living feel fresh and effortless. The spacious kitchen is equipped with modern appliances, a center island, and a breakfast bar for.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


415 smith street fort collins, CO 80524 Old Town	5 Beds 2 Baths 2344 Fin SqFt Close Price: Close Date: 2025-06-12 List Price: $825,000 # of Photos Avail: 40 V-tour Available: No MLS #: IR1031803 Status: closed Listing Office: homesmart realty partners ftc	Broker Remarks: OLD TOWN FORT COLLINS - these words connote a certain ambiance unparalleled on this side of town! 415 Smith St is ideally located close to Old Town Square and the Public Library. This well maintained 5 bedroom-2 bath home sits on a 9,500 sq ft lot with alley access. The main level has nicely refinished oak floors, 3 bedrooms and a full bath, an updated kitchen with beautiful oak cabinets, stainless steel appliances & granite countertops. The garden level basement can be set up as a separate living quarters and has a living room, 2 bedrooms and a full bath, full kitchen and outside entrances in.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


226 cajetan street fort collins, CO 80524 Old Town	4 Beds 4 Baths 2497 Fin SqFt Close Price: Close Date: 2025-06-09 List Price: $869,000 # of Photos Avail: 40 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1033187 Status: closed Listing Office: exp realty - northern co	Broker Remarks: Live the vibrant Old Town Fort Collins lifestyle in this 4 bed, 4 bath urban oasis with unforgettable outdoor spaces and smart upgrades featuring a robust 5.48kW solar array. Wow your guests on your rooftop patio with 360 degree views and unobstructed sunsets over the Rocky Mountains from your hot tub and a one-of-a-kind multi-tiered side-yard with natural stonework, garden beds, fire pit, bocce ball court, and an outdoor TV. Inside, you'll find vaulted ceilings, a 3-sided fireplace, custom reclaimed wooden details throughout, quality luxury vinyl plank flooring on all levels, and designer lig.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


412 lilac lane fort collins, CO 80524 Old Town	2 Beds 1 Baths 714 Fin SqFt Close Price: Close Date: 2025-06-02 List Price: $485,000 # of Photos Avail: 19 V-tour Available: No MLS #: IR1027321 Status: closed Listing Office: re/max alliance-ftc dwtn	Broker Remarks: Check out this turn key, move-in ready bungalow with all the features you might expect to see in more expensive homes at a price that won't break the budget. Not all Old Town homes are created equal! Fully permitted renovation in 2019 blends the modern features you appreciate in old town living with the charm and character of the homes along Lilac Lane, a quaint, non-through street just blocks from downtown, shopping, bike trails & a commuter's dream being just minutes to I-25 w/out the crosstown traffic. Top of the line Marvin Infinity windows along with spray foam attic insulation provide ma.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


425 e laurel street fort collins, CO 80524 Old Town	4 Beds 3 Baths 2675 Fin SqFt Close Price: Close Date: 2025-05-30 List Price: $1,297,000 # of Photos Avail: 40 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1032650 Status: closed Listing Office: c3 real estate solutions, llc	Broker Remarks: Live the idyllic Old Town Fort Collins Lifestyle! This amazing Historic GEM is Phenomenal in every way with a newer kitchen remodel + built-in's! On the FTC Historic Home & Garden Tour! expansive and open Main Floor Living, and has been Reimagined + Remodeled to perfection, Local Professional Designer's Own Home- could be right out of Sunset Magazine! Every thoughtful detail encompassing some of the finest Old Town Charm. Easy Bike or Walk into Old Town Square, Parks, Restaurants, Shopping, Bars, Live Music + Festivals! Ideal Accents + Design at every turn, a Living Treasure Inside + Out! Na.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


307 s loomis avenue fort collins, CO 80521 Old Town	6 Beds 4 Baths 2928 Fin SqFt Close Price: Close Date: 2025-05-30 List Price: $1,695,000 # of Photos Avail: 40 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1033051 Status: closed Listing Office: compass - boulder	Broker Remarks: At 307 S. Loomis, history is not preserved-it is elevated. This singular Fort Collins residence, masterfully reinterpreted in a 2025 architectural renovation, delivers a level of detail and restraint that speaks directly to the luxury client who values provenance as much as precision. Set in the heart of Old Town, the Traditional Folk Victorian exterior-featuring clear grain Douglas Fir lap siding, a Catslide roofline and era-true color palette-is a subtle but confident nod to the past, while the interiors embrace a standard of finish more often found in international design publications than .. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


1212 w mountain avenue fort collins, CO 80521 Old Town	6 Beds 2 Baths 2958 Fin SqFt Close Price: Close Date: 2025-05-28 List Price: $1,775,000 # of Photos Avail: 38 V-tour Available: No MLS #: IR1031652 Status: closed Listing Office: downtown real estate brokers	Broker Remarks: An absolutely one-of-a-kind 6 bed, 2 bath, Dutch Gable Mountain Avenue stunner built in 1911, offering 4225 square feet located on a 9,556 sf lot with an orchard, raised garden beds, and old-growth trees.The main floor boasts 1618 square feet set off by 11 foot ceilings, refinished wood floors, two large bedrooms, one full bathroom, two very large living rooms, a stunning built-in original wood and glass hutch, and a massive kitchen with a cozy den, a large island, additional bar seating and room for a full dining room.The 1267 Square foot basement is nearly finished and low-hanging fruit for .. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


816 maple street fort collins, CO 80521 Old Town	2 Beds 2 Baths 882 Fin SqFt Close Price: Close Date: 2025-05-13 List Price: $695,000 # of Photos Avail: 26 V-tour Available: No MLS #: IR1025267 Status: closed Listing Office: the real estate workshop llc	Broker Remarks: Charming 2-bedroom, 2-bath bungalow ideally situated in the heart of historic Old Town, on the highly sought-after Maple Street. This immaculately maintained home is bathed in natural light thanks to its abundance of windows. The beautifully landscaped yard features a covered front porch with a swing, vibrant flower beds, mature trees, and a convenient sprinkler system. The spacious primary bedroom includes an ensuite bathroom and offers direct access to a private back deck, perfect for relaxing. Also includes a flex space loft area. Enjoy all the charm and conveniences of Old Town living in t.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


339 pascal street fort collins, CO 80524 Old Town	3 Beds 3 Baths 2709 Fin SqFt Close Price: Close Date: 2025-05-12 List Price: $1,125,000 # of Photos Avail: 40 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1030108 Status: closed Listing Office: c3 real estate solutions, llc	Broker Remarks: Rarely does this kind of property present, a unique treasure in Old Town North- Backing to HOA protected Open Space, beautiful tree grove, trails + phenomenal Mountain Views! A Colorado lifestyle "experience" - Enjoy tranquil Sunsets - spacious outdoor living areas, an excellent entertainer's haven! The best of all worlds, Modern & Comfortable Old Town living, Stellar Views + Open Space, Low maintenance + a Stunning 3 car tandem garage for all your Colorado toys (fully finished, insulated w/ epoxy floors!) Finished lower level walk-out to the front! Bathed in sunshine, with spacious picture wi.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures

Next >>
Searches For Homes Near Old Town Fort Collins: See All Fort Collins Homes For Sale See All Putnam Elementary School Homes For Sale See All Lincoln Junior High / Middle School Homes For Sale See All Poudre Senior High School Homes For Sale The content relating to real estate for sale in this web site comes in part from the Internet Data eXchange ("IDX") program of METROLIST, INC., DBA RECOLORADO® Real estate listings held by brokers other than The Brian Petrelli Team are marked with the IDX Logo. This information is being provided for the consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose. All information subject to change and should be independently verified.