Sold Homes in Horsetooth Lake Estates, Fort Collins

Your Horsetooth Lake Estates, Fort Collins Homes Specialists

Area Information

Sold Home Stats
- Sold Home Stats for
  Horsetooth Lake Estates
  2025 - 2026
  # of Sold Homes: 13
  Avg. Sold Price: $590,692
  
  Horsetooth Lake Estates Fort Collins Sold Homes
  
  Horsetooth Lake Estates Fort Collins Housing Market Report

Home Search

Property Type:
Single Family
Condo / Townhome

City:

Neighborhood:

Zip:

Price:
TO:

Bedrooms:

Bathrooms:

For a more detailed home search, click For a more detailed home search, click here

HOA Contact
- Management Contact:
  Horsetooth Lake Estates
- Management Phone:
  970-237-3835
- Search all Denver Metro HOAs
Household Income
- Under $25,000:
  21.7%
- $25,000-$34,999:
  9.1%
- $35,000-$49,999:
  14%
- $50,000-$74,999:
  18.5%
- $75,000-$99,9999:
  14.1%
- $100,000-$149,999:
  13.9%
- $150,000-$199,999:
  4.8%
- $200,000+:
  3.8%
- Based on zip code.
  Source: U.S. Census Bureau
Education Level
- High School:
  96.3%
- College:
  48.7%
- Graduate and Above:
  18.7%
- Based on zip code.
  Source: U.S. Census Bureau
Crime Rates
- Agency Reporting:
  Fort Collins Police Dept
- Total Population:
  148,792
- Violent Crime Total:
  391
- Murder / Manslaughter:
  2
- Forecible Rape:
  44
- Robery:
  40
- Aggrivated Assault:
  305
- Property Crime Total:
  4,119
- Burglary:
  598
- Larceny / Theft:
  3,379
- Vehicle Theft:
  142
- Sources: FBI, Uniform Crime Reports, prepared by the National Archive of Criminal Justice Data

The Brian Petrelli Team is your Horsetooth Lake Estates , Fort Collins home specialist.

Horsetooth Lake Estates Community Information:

Primary HOA Fees*:
$340.00 / Annually

Secondary HOA Fees*:
$0.00 /

*HOA fees shown are from the most recent listings. Please contact our team or check each property individually for accurate HOA fees. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed.

HOA Ammenities:
-
-Reserves

Horsetooth Lake Estates , Fort Collins has had 13 homes sell in the past two years for an average sales price of $590,692.

Our team of local Fort Collins experts have over 200 years of combined expertise in the Colorado Real Estate market. Give us a call today to put our knowledge and experience to work for you as you buy or sell your next Horsetooth Lake Estates home.

Don't see what you're looking for here? Contact our team for a free, custom search.

The Brian Petrelli Team
Phone:303-726-1874
[email protected]

Click here to create your own custom home search. You will be able to search every Fort Collins houses currently on the market.

Fort Collins Home Searches

Fort Collins 55 And Over Communities

Fort Collins Single Family Homes

Fort Collins Buyer's Agent Information


All Sold Horsetooth Lake Estates Fort Collins Homes: (Showing most recent sold homes. For complete results, Search All Sold Homes Here) See All Active Horsetooth Lake Estates Fort Collins Homes For Sale


Your search resulted in 13 Total Homes. Now viewing listings 1 through 13.
Viewing Page 1 of 1. \| Go to Page Go \|

5416 continental drive fort collins, CO 80526 Horsetooth Lake Estates	3 Beds 2 Baths 1649 Fin SqFt Close Price: $653,076 Close Date: 2026-05-27 List Price: $675,000 # of Photos Avail: 33 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1055539 Status: closed Listing Office: re/max alliance-wellington	Broker Remarks: Experience the perfect blend of mountain living and everyday convenience in this beautifully updated home just minutes from Fort Collins. Ideally situated near Horsetooth Mountain Open Space, this property offers unmatched access to hiking, biking, and wildlife, while Horsetooth Reservoir is just a quick five-minute drive away for boating, paddleboarding, and lakeside relaxation. Set on a spacious .4-acre lot, this 2,240 square foot home features 3 bedrooms (3rd bedroom non-conforming) and 2 bathrooms, thoughtfully designed to capture the beauty of its natural surroundings. Inside, you'll find.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


120 sandhill lane fort collins, CO 80526 Horsetooth Lake Estates	2 Beds 3 Baths 2060 Fin SqFt Close Price: $630,000 Close Date: 2026-05-14 List Price: $630,000 # of Photos Avail: 29 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1054680 Status: closed Listing Office: group centerra	Broker Remarks: Nestled in the desirable Horsetooth area of Fort Collins, this inviting home offers the perfect blend of natural beauty and comfortable living just minutes from Horsetooth Reservoir. Surrounded by open space and scenic views, the property provides a peaceful setting while still being conveniently close to town.The abundant natural light, welcoming living spaces or the spacious deck, all are perfect for enjoying Colorado sunsets, entertaining, or simply taking in the peaceful surroundings of the Horsetooth foothills.The primary bedroom is located on the main floor, providing both comfort and co.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


5220 arrowhead lane fort collins, CO 80526 Horsetooth Lake Estates	3 Beds 3 Baths 2628 Fin SqFt Close Price: $680,000 Close Date: 2026-05-14 List Price: $680,000 # of Photos Avail: 45 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1055890 Status: closed Listing Office: group mulberry	Broker Remarks: Wake up to views of Horsetooth Rock and step outside to one of Colorado's most beloved outdoor playgrounds. Tucked in Horsetooth Lake Estates - just across 38E from Horsetooth Mountain Park and minutes from the Reservoir - this home delivers a rare mountain retreat close to town. Southwestern vibes are woven throughout, from warm earth tones and rustic finishes to vaulted ceilings and a one-of-a-kind eat-in kitchen - creating a cozy, distinctive atmosphere that sets this home apart. Three bedrooms upstairs include a large primary suite with a full bathroom, walk-in closet, and deck with those .. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


5061 fawn lane fort collins, CO 80526 Horsetooth Lake Estates	3 Beds 2 Baths 1442 Fin SqFt Close Price: $670,000 Close Date: 2026-04-07 List Price: $670,000 # of Photos Avail: 34 V-tour Available: No MLS #: IR1053640 Status: closed Listing Office: group mulberry	Broker Remarks: Come check out this unique foothills retreat, just minutes away from Horsetooth Reservoir! Enjoy the incredible views and outdoor lifestyle(hiking/mountain biking/kayaking/paddle boards) from your doorstep, but still only minutes away from Fort Collins. The interior has been completely repainted, with new carpet in all bedrooms and stairwell. The main level is flooded with natural light, including windows at the peak of the tall vaulted ceilings. The living room has newer LVP, with a pellet stove for warmth. The wraparound trex deck from the front of the home along the eastern edge, taking adv.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


4817 catalina drive fort collins, CO 80526 Horsetooth Lake Estates	3 Beds 2 Baths 1296 Fin SqFt Close Price: $435,000 Close Date: 2026-03-04 List Price: $450,000 # of Photos Avail: 45 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1048276 Status: closed Listing Office: resident realty	Broker Remarks: Check out this wonderful ranch style home just steps away from the shorelines of Horsetooth reservoir! This 3 bed, 2 bath newly remodeled home has a 2 car detached garage and a huge yard with 6' privacy fence. Lots of improvements include but not limited to: fresh interior and exterior paint, new windows throughout, new vinyl flooring throughout, all new appliances, and new roof and gutters! NO HOA and plenty of room for all your toys! Enjoy that rural feeling of the foothills while being close to all the conveniences of Fort Collins. Moor your boat at Inlet Bay Marina just a few minutes walk .. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


5000 foothills drive fort collins, CO 80526 Horsetooth Lake Estates	4 Beds 2 Baths 2243 Fin SqFt Close Price: $465,000 Close Date: 2026-01-09 List Price: $500,000 # of Photos Avail: 50 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1044095 Status: closed Listing Office: re/max alliance-loveland	Broker Remarks: Motivated Seller-bring all offers! Come and see how livable this home is. Just moments from Horsetooth Reservoir in a location that puts you close to everything outdoors: hiking, biking, swimming, fishing, boating, and miles of stunning trails. The Blue Sky Trailhead is just 0.4 miles away and connects all the way to Devil's Backbone in Loveland, giving you endless options for adventure. This roomy, single-level home has been refreshed with new interior paint, new carpet, and new luxury vinyl in the bathrooms and laundry room. The inviting living room features clerestory windows that flood the.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


5001 w county road 38 fort collins, CO 80526 Horsetooth Lake Estates	3 Beds 1 Baths 1088 Fin SqFt Close Price: $495,000 Close Date: 2025-09-23 List Price: $499,000 # of Photos Avail: 39 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1039156 Status: closed Listing Office: assist 2 sell - ortiz realty	Broker Remarks: This exceptional property, Custom-Built in 1997, offers a Perfect blend of Country Charm and Contemporary Living. It is set on a Generous 0.63-acre Lot and Boasts Panoramic Mountain Views. Features a welcoming Covered Front Porch, and Significant Updates have been made since its Original Construction-New Class 4 ROOF on July 24, 2025.The interior includes a gas-burning log stove in the living room, creating a cozy atmosphere. The main floor primary bedroom, laundry facilities, and a full bathroom. (1 Room non-compliant) A two-car garage provides ample space. The property is ideally located jus.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


4945 sandstone drive fort collins, CO 80526 Horsetooth Lake Estates	3 Beds 2 Baths 1440 Fin SqFt Close Price: $630,000 Close Date: 2025-08-15 List Price: $575,000 # of Photos Avail: 40 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1039822 Status: closed Listing Office: re/max alliance-ftc south	Broker Remarks: Savy buyers shop smart! Lock in 5.6% interest for 5 years with ENT Credit Union to buy this PREINSPECTED home. Live where you play-with hiking, biking, boating, swimming, and paddleboarding just steps from your front door in beautiful Horsetooth Lake Estates. Tucked away on a private 1/3 acre lot, this home is designed to take in the views. Backing to open space are massive, recently installed windows and two expansive decks offer stunning scenery from nearly every angle. Step inside through the owner's entrance and be greeted by a practical mudroom/drop zone. The main level features a cozy br.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


4624 echo circle fort collins, CO 80526 Horsetooth Lake Estates	2 Beds 1 Baths 952 Fin SqFt Close Price: $421,600 Close Date: 2025-07-18 List Price: $425,000 # of Photos Avail: 27 V-tour Available: No MLS #: IR1036426 Status: closed Listing Office: dunn real estate & mgmt	Broker Remarks: WOW! What a view. Sunsets every night. If you are looking for the perfect foothills property just 10 minutes from town, this is it. Overlooking spectacular Horsetooth mountain park, this property is close to hiking, biking, paddle boarding, fishing or just relaxing on the peaceful, quiet, spacious deck. The time is now to own your piece of paradise... more... View photos and more info Disclosures


144 sandhill lane fort collins, CO 80526 Horsetooth Lake Estates	3 Beds 2 Baths 2311 Fin SqFt Close Price: $650,000 Close Date: 2025-06-17 List Price: $650,000 # of Photos Avail: 39 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: IR1030791 Status: closed Listing Office: group mulberry	Broker Remarks: A truly unique Foothills retreat! This home perfectly blends vintage charm with stunning, unobstructed views of Horsetooth Mountain Open Space. Just minutes from Horsetooth Reservoir, it's an outdoor lover's paradise. Inside, you're welcomed by a bright living room filled with natural light, convenient built-ins, beautiful wood floors, and a cozy wood burning stove-perfect for relaxing with a good book. . The remodeled kitchen adds a fun and stylish touch featuring butcher block counters, farmhouse sink, blue herringbone tile, stainless steel appliances and a pantry. The separate dining room m.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


5000 sandstone drive fort collins, CO 80526 Horsetooth Lake Estates	3 Beds 2 Baths 1410 Fin SqFt Close Price: $745,000 Close Date: 2025-06-06 List Price: $775,000 # of Photos Avail: 29 V-tour Available: No MLS #: IR1031231 Status: closed Listing Office: group harmony	Broker Remarks: Enjoy breathtaking views of Longs Peak out front and Horsetooth Lake out back! This beautifully updated 3-bed, 2-bath ranch sits on nearly an acre and features an open layout, oak floors, and a large Trex deck perfect for soaking in the scenery. The kitchen boasts Corian counters, soft-close Hickory cabinets, pullout pantry drawers, and newer stainless appliances. The spacious primary suite offers wood floors, a large closet, and views of Longs Peak. Other highlights include a detached oversized 2-car garage, newer water heater, fenced yard, stamped concrete patio, and tasteful finishes throug.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


5001 holiday drive fort collins, CO 80526 Horsetooth Lake Estates	4 Beds 5 Baths 3392 Fin SqFt Close Price: $536,250 Close Date: 2025-05-19 List Price: $550,000 # of Photos Avail: 46 V-tour Available: Yes MLS #: 8131322 Status: closed Listing Office: key team real estate corp.	Broker Remarks: Welcome to Horsetooth Reservoir Estates – Where the Rockies Meet the Plains! Nestled in one of Northern Colorado’s most scenic and sought-after communities, this unique property offers the best of both worlds: mountain and prairie living with access to the stunning Horsetooth Reservoir. Enjoy endless outdoor adventures right outside your door including fishing, boating, camping, swimming, scuba diving, rock climbing, water skiing, and more. This versatile prefab home is truly two homes in one! The main level features a spacious, open-concept design with 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a dedicat.. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


4721 overhill drive fort collins, CO 80526 Horsetooth Lake Estates	3 Beds 2 Baths 2100 Fin SqFt Close Price: $606,000 Close Date: 2025-03-28 List Price: $600,000 # of Photos Avail: 18 V-tour Available: No MLS #: 1811769 Status: closed Listing Office: your castle real estate inc	Broker Remarks: Mountain Living Awaits! Ever dreamt of waking up to breathtaking mountain views and being just minutes away from the natural beauty and adventure of Horsetooth Lake and Horsetooth Mountain? This charming home in the Horsetooth Lake Estates subdivision is more than just a place to live—it's a gateway to an incredible lifestyle. This inviting home offers three comfortable bedrooms, two full bathrooms, and bright living spaces with vaulted ceilings that create an open and airy feel. The oversized two-car garage and boat/RV parking provide plenty of storage and convenience, and the spacious .. more... View photos and more info Disclosures


Searches For Homes Near Horsetooth Lake Estates Fort Collins: See All Fort Collins Homes For Sale See All McGraw Elementary School Homes For Sale See All Webber Junior High / Middle School Homes For Sale See All Rocky Mountain Senior High School Homes For Sale The content relating to real estate for sale in this web site comes in part from the Internet Data eXchange ("IDX") program of METROLIST, INC., DBA RECOLORADO® Real estate listings held by brokers other than The Brian Petrelli Team are marked with the IDX Logo. This information is being provided for the consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose. All information subject to change and should be independently verified.

All Cities
AKRON
ALLENSPARK
ALMA
ARAPAHOE
ARVADA
AULT
AURORA
AVON
BAILEY
BATTLEMENT MESA
BELLVUE
BENNETT
BERTHOUD
BEULAH
BLACK FOREST
BLACK HAWK
BLANCA
BOULDER
BOW MAR
BRIGGSDALE
BRIGHTON
BROOMFIELD
BRUSH
BUENA VISTA
BUFFALO CREEK
BURLINGTON
BYERS
CALHAN
CANON CITY
CAPULIN
CARBONDALE
CASCADE
CASTLE ROCK
CENTENNIAL
CENTRAL CITY
CHAMA
CHERRY HILLS VILLAGE
CHEYENNE WELLS
COALDALE
COLORADO CITY
COLORADO SPRINGS
COLUMBINE VALLEY
COMMERCE CITY
COMO
CONIFER
COPE
CRESTONE
CRIPPLE CREEK
DACONO
DECKERS
DEER TRAIL
DENVER
DIVIDE
DRAKE
DUMONT
DUPONT
EATON
EDGEWATER
EDWARDS
ELBERT
ELIZABETH
EMPIRE
ENGLEWOOD
ERIE
ESTES PARK
EVANS
EVERGREEN
FAIRPLAY
FEDERAL HEIGHTS
FIRESTONE
FLAGLER
FLORISSANT
FORT LUPTON
FORT MORGAN
FOUNTAIN
FOXFIELD
FOXTON
FRANKTOWN
FRASER
FREDERICK
FRISCO
GALETON
GENOA
GEORGETOWN
GILCREST
GLADE PARK
GLENDALE
GLENWOOD SPRINGS
GOLDEN
GRANBY
GRAND JUNCTION
GRAND LAKE
GRANT
GREELEY
GREENWOOD VILLAGE
GUFFEY
GYPSUM
HARTSEL
HEENEY
HENDERSON
HIGHLANDS RANCH
HILLROSE
HOT SULPHUR SPRINGS
HOWARD
HUDSON
HUGO
IDAHO SPRINGS
IDALIA
IDLEDALE
INDIAN HILLS
JAMESTOWN
JEFFERSON
JOES
JOHNSTOWN
KEENESBURG
KERSEY
KEYSTONE
KIOWA
KIRK
KIT CARSON
KITTREDGE
KREMMLING
LA SALLE
LA VETA
LAFAYETTE
LAKE CITY
LAKE GEORGE
LAKEWOOD
LAPORTE
LARKSPUR
LAS ANIMAS
LEADVILLE
LIMON
LITTLETON
LIVERMORE
LOCHBUIE
LONE TREE
LONGMONT
LOUISVILLE
LOUVIERS
LOVELAND
LYONS
MANITOU SPRINGS
MATHESON
MEAD
MERINO
MILLIKEN
MONTROSE
MONUMENT
MORRISON
NATHROP
NEDERLAND
NEW RAYMER
NIWOT
NORTHGLENN
OAK CREEK
ORCHARD
OTIS
OURAY
OVID
PAGOSA SPRINGS
PALISADE
PALMER LAKE
PARKER
PARSHALL
PEYTON
PIERCE
PINE
PINECLIFFE
PLACERVILLE
PLATTEVILLE
PUEBLO
RAMAH
RED FEATHER LAKES
REDSTONE
RIDGWAY
RIFLE
ROCKY FORD
ROGGEN
ROLLINSVILLE
RUSH
RYE
SAGUACHE
SALIDA
SAN LUIS
SAN PABLO
SEDALIA
SEDGWICK
SEIBERT
SEVERANCE
SHAWNEE
SHERIDAN
SILVER PLUME
SILVERTHORNE
SIMLA
SNYDER
STEAMBOAT SPRINGS
STERLING
STRASBURG
STRATTON
SUPERIOR
TABERNASH
THORNTON
TRINIDAD
TWIN LAKES
VAIL
VICTOR
VILLA GROVE
WALDEN
WALSENBURG
WARD
WATKINS
WELDONA
WELLINGTON
WESTCLIFFE
WESTMINSTER
WHEAT RIDGE
WIGGINS
WILEY
WINDSOR
WINTER PARK
WOODLAND PARK
WRAY
YODER

Your Horsetooth Lake Estates, Fort Collins Homes Specialists

Horsetooth Lake Estates Community Information:

Fort Collins Home Searches

All Sold Horsetooth Lake Estates Fort Collins Homes:

Searches For Homes Near Horsetooth Lake Estates Fort Collins: